A Comprehensive Guide to Emotional Support Animals and Air Travel
If you have an emotional support animal (ESA) and want to bring them along on a flight, you’ve probably come across situations where airlines have denied your request. From my experience helping many clients navigate ESA policies, I’ve seen how confusing and frustrating this can be. In this article, I’ll provide a thorough explanation of the laws regarding ESAs and air travel to help you understand your rights and options.
Defining Emotional Support Animals
Let’s start with the basics. An ESA, as defined by the Department of Transportation (DOT), is an animal that provides therapeutic benefit to an individual with a mental or psychiatric disability. This is different than a service animal, which is specifically trained to perform tasks for an individual with a disability. To legally qualify as an ESA, a person must have a mental health condition documented by a medical professional, such as a physician or mental health professional. A letter of accommodation from this medical professional is needed to bring an ESA on a plane. Airlines are not allowed to request any documentation of a person’s disability itself under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA).
Airline Policies on ESAs
While the DOT views ESAs similarly to service animals when it comes to travel, airlines themselves can have varying policies on allowing ESAs in the cabin. Under DOT rules, most domestic commercial flights must allow passengers with ESAs to travel with their animal in the cabin at no additional cost, only requesting the letter from a medical provider. However, some airlines have recently begun restricting this, basically only allowing ESAs in the cargo hold or as carry-on pets. Many frustrated passengers have faced situations where their ESAs have been denied at check-in despite having proper documentation.
Common Issues with ESA Documentation
From handling many cases involving ESA issues, there are some red flags I’ve noticed that often lead to an airline denying a request. One is using an online medical form instead of an original letter from a medical provider who has a previous relationship with the patient. The DOT views online ESA registry certifications and forms as inadequate. The letter must come directly from a licensed mental health professional the patient has seen in-person. Notes written by a friend or family member practicing telehealth would also not suffice. Unfortunately, some patients lack a long-term treatment provider able to write an appropriate letter, which contributes to denials.
Dealing with an ESA Request Denial
If your ESA request is denied at the airport, it’s important to remain calm and understand your rights. You can politely ask to speak to a airline supervisor to provide more information regarding the reason for denial and DOT guidelines. Be prepared to show your medical letter and have your provider available if needed. If still denied, request the airline’s formal complaint process and file a complaint with the DOT afterwards. Getting denied can be infuriating, but keeping your composure and following procedure is key to getting the issue resolved. The DOT takes ESA accommodation complaints very seriously from passengers.
Alternatives If Your ESA Is Denied
If all efforts to have your ESA approved for a flight fail, you basically have three options. One is to check your ESA as oversized luggage/cargo for a fee if the airline allows this. Although not ideal being separated from your animal, it’s better than not traveling together. Another is seeing if driving or taking a train is feasible instead of flying if distance allows. A third is exploring if telehealth therapy sessions could effectively replace needing your ESA for the duration of travel if it’s a brief trip. In a pinch, alternatives may be worth considering over missing your travel plans entirely due to a denial.
Preparing Properly Ahead of Time
To avoid issues, it’s crucial to plan well in advance of travel. Make sure to contact the specific airline directly to understand their ESA policies beforehand. Get a bonafide letter from a licensed mental health professional you’ve had ongoing treatment with. Consider double-checking the letter meets all DOT requirements before check-in day. Also confirm your ESA is well-behaved, house trained, and any vaccination records are up to date. Proper preparation can help tremendously! Even with all documentation in order though, some people will still face denials from certain airlines at this time due to changing policies.
Potential Changes to ESA Laws on the Horizon
This kind of situation has become a huge issue for airlines and passengers alike. As a result, proposed changes to ESA laws and policies are currently being considered. Some possibilities include airlines only being required to accept ESAs in the cabin if they have successfully completed a public access training program, like service animals. Or standardized forms could be required and abuse better addressed. Ultimately though, people with legitimate needs for their mental health ESAs deserve accommodation protections too. It’s a complex problem with arguments on both sides. Hopefully a sensible solution can be found that respects all parties involved.
Navigating Uncertainty with Patience and Understanding
In summary, while the current ESA policies cause major hassles, try approaching each situation with an open and understanding mindset. Airlines face undue burdens from unrealistic ESA claims that they have to navigate. And people genuinely rely on their ESAs too. Both require empathy. By cooperating fully, keeping appropriate documentation, being prepared, and following proper complaint procedures respectfully if denied – hopefully a fair resolution can be found. Of course, this whole process causes stress and anxiety for many. But keeping perspective and avoiding hostility benefits all involved as changes to this evolving area of law and policy continue to take shape.
In the end, air travel accessibility issues are multi-layered with valid concerns on each side. As a society, ideally we can strike a reasonable compromise where people’s mental well-being needs are supported in a responsible way that doesn’t place unfair hardship on businesses either. With open communication and understanding between all parties, I think progress toward better solutions is possible.
Airlines Banning Emotional Support Animals
| Airline | Effective Date | Requirements |
|---|---|---|
| Delta | January 11, 2021 | Only service animals are allowed. Requires DOT/HUD form and documentation from licensed mental health professional. |
| United | January 1, 2022 | Only service animals are allowed. Documentation must state the need for the animal, animal’s training, tasks it performs. |
| American | December 31, 2021 | Only service animals are allowed. Requires veterinary health form and training documentation. |
| Alaska Airlines | January 15, 2022 | Only service animals are allowed. Requires DOT/HUD form and letter from licensed healthcare provider. |
| Southwest | Currently allows ESAs. | If policy changes, documentation would be required as with the other airlines. |
FAQ
-
Why aren’t emotional support animals allowed on planes anymore?
Basically, airlines say emotional support animals kind of cause issues. Lots of people started bringing all kinds of animals on planes that weren’t properly trained. It was sort of causing problems for other passengers. Now the rules are more strict about what animals are actually needed as service animals.
-
Is it fair that airlines get to decide what is and isn’t an emotional support animal?
On the one hand, airlines are private businesses that need to consider safety and comfort for everyone flying. However, it also seems not right that they alone get to determine people’s medical needs. Perhaps there should be some agreed standards. But who decides that? At the same time, some folks took advantage before to bring untrained pets which is not fair to real support animals. It’s a tricky situation with reasonable arguments on both sides.
-
What type of animals are usually allowed as emotional support animals?
Typically, dogs and cats are commonly approved as emotional support animals. Small animals like rabbits, pigs and miniature horses have also been permitted in some cases. Birds or reptiles are less likely to make the cut. I suppose it depends on the animal’s size and how well-behaved it is. At the end of the day, the decision lies with each airline.
-
How can you tell if someone really needs an emotional support animal or is just trying to bring their pet on a plane?
That’s a tough one! I don’t really have a surefire way to know someone else’s situation. But airlines might ask for documentation from a medical professional saying the animal provides emotional support relevant to a disability. Of course, paperwork doesn’t always prove the full picture – who’s to say if the need is real or fake? Perhaps there should be some standard vetting, no pun intended! At the same time, we shouldn’t judge others too harshly.
-
Do you need any special training as an emotional support animal?
If an animal is to accompany someone in public areas like planes or housing with “no pets” policies, it makes sense that the animal demonstrate good behavior. Amazingly, many untrained pets were masquerading before! Going forward, appropriate training for service roles would be prudent. But again, how much is enough? There are no simple answers here.
In the end, it’s a complex problem with good intentions on both sides. Reasonable accommodation for disabilities needs to be balanced with other passengers’ well-being. Perhaps if the rules were more clear and standardized, it would alleviate concerns. But what do you think – have airlines gone too far in restricting support animals? Or were previous polices taking advantage of too easily? I’d love to hear other perspectives on this tricky issue!